Parent Loans ‘Fraught With Peril’ As Default Rates Hit 20, 30 Percent at Many Colleges

The debate over how one can resolve the nation’s pupil debt disaster is heating up once more, as strain builds on President Joe Biden to increase the pandemic pause on repayments attributable to expire in September and progressives renew calls to forgive a few of the $1.6 trillion that Americans owe. Advocates communicate eloquently in regards to the pressure school debt places on younger folks beginning out in life: They cannot pay their payments, get married, purchase a house, begin a household or, typically, transfer out of their mother and father’ basements. Typically omitted of the dialogue: these mother and father, lots of whom are weighed down by school loans of their very own—struggling to pay their payments or save for the longer term, pressured to postpone retirement or marvel if they will ever have the ability to retire in any respect.

One out of each 4 federal {dollars} lent for undergraduate training final yr went to folks and a surprising 22 % of that $1.6 trillion in excellent pupil debt, $336 billion in all, is held by folks 50 and older, who usually borrowed to assist pay for a kid’s or grandchild’s greater training. Those numbers replicate an explosion in borrowing in recent times fueled by hovering tuition charges, a change in guidelines that has made it simpler for folks to get loans and, in some instances, aggressive advertising techniques by faculties that prompted extra mother and father to borrow, in bigger quantities. Over the previous decade, a time when lending to undergraduates has truly been falling, dad or mum borrowing underneath the federal PLUS mortgage program has elevated 16 %; over the previous three many years, it is shot up greater than 750 %, the College Board studies.

Now, a brand new Newsweek evaluation of parent-loan knowledge just lately launched by the federal authorities exhibits how rapidly many of those mother and father run into severe issues repaying what they owe, how deeply within the gap they’re, which faculties have essentially the most severe issues and the way a lot of a pressure mother and father’ school debt places on the households that may least afford them.

According to the info, which covers almost 1,000 schools and universities that participated within the federal Parent PLUS mortgage program from 2017 to 2019, almost one in 10 mother and father default or are severely late with funds inside simply two years of their baby leaving college. That dad or mum default and delinquency charge hit 20 % or extra at over 150 faculties and not less than 30 to 40 % at dozens of establishments—a charge excessive sufficient for an establishment to lose federal funding if the loans had been made to undergraduates as an alternative of oldsters.

The majority of those PLUS debtors—almost six in 10, within the Newsweek database—are from low-income households, busting the parable that it is primarily prosperous mother and father, who can comfortably afford their funds, who take out these loans. At over 140 of the 979 faculties analyzed, 80 % or extra of the dad or mum debtors have been from low-income houses.

FE_Parent Debt_01
Young folks aren’t the one ones grabbling with the ball and chain of school debt.

The issues are notably acute at for-profit faculties, the Newsweek evaluation discovered. Default charges at these establishments, the place three-quarters of the debtors have been usually from low-income households, ran double the nationwide common—a very dangerous discount for the mother and father shelling out this cash given the traditionally low commencement charges at many of those faculties. Among schools the place PLUS-loan default and delinquency charges have been not less than double the nationwide common, one other roughly 30 % have been traditionally Black schools and universities, which rely closely on dad or mum loans attributable to institutional underfunding and a larger-than-average share of scholars coming from lower-income households.

Even if they are not falling behind on funds, the quantities mother and father borrow—excess of their kids, usually—put a pressure on budgets for a lot of households. Newsweek has recognized greater than 150 faculties the place the median dad or mum mortgage is greater than the utmost $27,000 college students usually are allowed to borrow in federal loans over 4 years and greater than two dozen faculties the place dad or mum loans usually exceed $50,000.

Something wants to alter drastically, says Richard Fossey, a professor of training legislation and coverage on the University of Louisiana, who has referred to as on Congress to abolish the Parent PLUS program. Says Fossey, writer of The Student Loan Catastrophe, “There are ways to go to school without putting parents in debt and people need to figure it out.”

In addition to the non-public disaster these loans create for a lot of households, specialists warn of the potential for severe injury to the U.S. financial system if waves of dad or mum debtors default. Betsy Mayotte, president of The Institute of Student Loan Advisors, likens the state of affairs to the 2008 mortgage disaster, when giant numbers of new-home debtors erroneously assumed that, if a financial institution stated they certified for the mortgage, that meant they may afford to repay the debt. When giant numbers of house owners subsequently defaulted, the nation was plunged into the worst financial downturn because the Great Depression.

In testimony about dad or mum loans at a U.S. Department of Education listening to final month, Mayotte stated: “In any other forum, the practice of awarding loans in large amounts without regard to the borrower’s ability to pay, while not providing tools for relief, would be considered predatory and unconscionable.” Talking with Newsweek, she put it this fashion: “The Parent PLUS program is fraught with peril—for families and for the U.S. taxpayer.”

‘The Money Just Kept Coming’

In the 2019-20 college yr, in keeping with the latest federal knowledge, mother and father of almost 754,000 school college students took out PLUS loans, borrowing a mean of $16,305. Like authorities loans for undergraduates, these loans generally is a boon for faculty entry, permitting households who would have had hassle paying for varsity assist their kids get a level.

There are key variations, although, between the federal loans that college students take out to pay for his or her greater training and those accessible to their mother and father—variations that enhance the monetary dangers. For one factor, the quantities that folks can borrow are a lot greater: as much as the total price of attendance, together with room, board, charges and different bills, minus any monetary assist the scholar receives. By distinction, loans to conventional undergraduates are usually capped at $5,500 to $7,500 a yr.

The price of borrowing for folks is greater too: 6.28 % for the 2021-22 educational yr plus an upfront price of 4.228 %, versus 3.73 % for undergraduate loans with a 1.057 % price. Repayment begins as quickly as the cash is disbursed whereas college students have an automated six-month grace interval after commencement earlier than funds start. Parents can elect to defer too however curiosity accrues from the second the primary greenback is disbursed.

The Newsweek evaluation exhibits how rapidly these quantities can add up. At Spelman College in Atlanta, for instance, the median PLUS mortgage for folks with a baby who graduated or left college between 2017 and 2019 was almost $85,000, the very best of any college within the database. Also within the high 10, by mortgage quantity: NYU in New York, with a median mortgage of almost $67,000 and Loyola Marymount in Los Angeles, at $60,500. Many faculties specializing within the arts have been additionally amongst these with the most important loans, together with Pratt Institute in Brooklyn, New York; Ringling College of Art and Design in Sarasota, Florida; Berklee College of Music in Boston and Savannah College of Art and Design in Georgia.

FE_Parent Debt_03
Graduation at Spelman College, the place the standard dad or mum borrows almost $85,000 to place their baby by way of college.
Paras Griffin/Getty

And that is only for one baby. Consider that some mother and father take out these loans for a number of kids and it is simple to see how huge of a weight PLUS borrowing can develop to be. Perhaps surprisingly, the info exhibits that dad or mum default and delinquency charges are literally lower-than-average at lots of the faculties related to the most important PLUS loans. But the staggering quantities should be inflicting hardship, straining present residing bills and prompting some mother and father to rethink when and the way they will have the ability to retire.

That’s the case for Phil Bender, a former public- college superintendent in Venice, Florida. When the oldest of his three daughters enrolled at Indiana’s Butler University in 2014, the household was in a position to pay for the primary yr from financial savings. But when a university monetary assist officer floated the concept of Parent PLUS loans, they appeared like the precise name in subsequent years, Bender says.

FE_Parent Debt_06
Parent Phil Bender of Venice, Florida, who has $300,000 in school loans for his three daughters, together with eldest Korey.
Courtesy of Dr. Phil Bender

Within 4 years, Bender’s two different daughters had enrolled in school—one at Robert Morris University in Chicago (since merged into Roosevelt University) and the opposite on the public Florida Gulf Coast University—and he had taken out 10 extra loans to pay for it. Today, with accrued curiosity, Bender owes greater than $300,000. He deferred fee whereas the three women attended graduate college however his oldest graduates this spring and he is aware of what’s coming.

“I’m 66 years old and the chance of this debt being paid off in my lifetime is pretty slim.”

“I’m 66 years old and the chance of this debt being paid off in my lifetime is pretty slim,” says Bender, who expects to owe as much as $1,400 monthly for the loans. He’s retired from his superintendent place however now consults and substitute teaches and doubts he’ll ever have the ability to cease working fully.

“Looking back, it was a huge mistake, I don’t think it should have been that easy,” Bender says. “Nobody seemed to be very interested in how I was going to pay them back, the money just kept coming.”

Few Barriers to Borrowing

For higher or for worse, the Department of Education does make it simple for households to get PLUS loans—too simple, many specialists say.

The software course of solely takes about 20 minutes, in keeping with the division’s web site, and would not ask for any details about earnings or different money owed to assist decide whether or not a borrower can afford to repay the mortgage. There’s a credit score verify but it surely’s cursory at greatest: As lengthy because the applicant is not 90 or extra days late on debt over $2,085 and hasn’t had a chapter, foreclosures or comparable setback throughout the previous 5 years, the mortgage shall be authorized.

“The result is that some parents are on the hook for debt most lenders never would have granted in the first place,” says Sandy Baum, a senior fellow on the Urban Institute’s Center on Education Data and Policy and writer of Student Debt: Rhetoric and Realities of Higher Education Financing.

At the 979 faculties for which Newsweek has knowledge, 58 % of dad or mum loans went to lower-income households; at for-profit faculties, the determine jumped to 75 %. And there have been not less than 45 faculties the place 90 % or extra of dad or mum debtors had low incomes.

One of these faculties is LeMoyne-Owen College, a personal traditionally Black college in Memphis, the place Enger Johnson’s son Marquez was recruited to play basketball a few years in the past. Johnson, 46, had simply moved out of a homeless shelter when she sat down with one of many school’s monetary assist officers, intent on discovering a technique to afford the college. She ended up signing the paperwork to borrow by way of the Parent PLUS program; trying again, she’s not fairly positive the way it occurred and did not perceive what the mortgage entailed.

Now working as a safety guard in Memphis, Johnson is behind on funds—almost a 3rd of the college’s dad or mum debtors are delinquent or have defaulted on their loans, in keeping with the federal knowledge—and besieged by assortment calls. She says appeals to the college for assist have gone nowhere. “I explained to them I was just coming out of the shelter after being homeless,” she stated. “I was getting back on my feet. But whenever I call, I can’t get anyone over there.”

LeMoyne-Owen’s monetary assist director, Amanda Headen, who wasn’t within the place when Johnson obtained her mortgage, stated she was disillusioned to listen to what had occurred and deliberate to do what she might to repair it. But the info suggests Johnson’s state of affairs shouldn’t be fully unusual—both at LeMoyne-Owen or different faculties depending on dad or mum loans for funding.

FE_Parent Debt_08
Former Education Secretary Arne Duncan couldn’t make a change in standards stick.
Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis/Getty

The federal authorities did make one try to tighten PLUS mortgage standards a decade in the past however the effort didn’t go nicely. The reforms led to a spike in mortgage denials, and a few faculties that relied closely on dad or mum borrowing, together with many HBCUs, argued they have been being unfairly focused. The ensuing backlash led to an apology from then-Education Secretary Arne Duncan and a loosening of the foundations once more in 2014.

Among the members of Congress who pressured the division to alter its thoughts was Democratic Representative James Clyburn of South Carolina, who stated stricter credit score checks had made it notably tough for Black mother and father to ship their kids to school.

“We keep putting rules out there knowing full well the rule has a more adverse impact on people of color.”

“We keep putting rules out there knowing full well the rule has a more adverse impact on people of color,” Clyburn, now the House Majority Whip, tells Newsweek. “All you’ve got to do is look at the result. If you pass a law and the law has an adverse impact on Black students, it speaks for itself.”

It’s a Catch-22, say researchers who’ve studied the impression of PLUS loans on lower-income households and Black households. Looser credit score requirements enhance school entry for folks with restricted monetary sources however go away them with money owed they battle to pay. One out of each 5 PLUS debtors and greater than a 3rd of Black debtors have incomes beneath the federal poverty line, in keeping with Baum. More broadly, her analysis exhibits, six in 10 Black mother and father with PLUS loans can be thought of lower-income versus 25 % of white PLUS-loan holders.

FE_Parent Debt_09
House Majority Whip James Clyburn, who pushed again in opposition to tighter credit score checks for dad or mum loans a decade in the past and stays opposed now: “If you pass a law and the law has an adverse impact on Black students, it speaks for itself.”
Salwan Georges/The Washington Post/Getty

One signal of the issues this may occasionally trigger for households is the comparatively excessive PLUS mortgage default and delinquency charges at some HBCUs. Of the 182 faculties within the Newsweek database with a mixed charge that is not less than twice the median, three in 10 % have been traditionally Black establishments.

One of them is Philander Smith College, in Little Rock, Arkansas, the place greater than 9 out of 10 PLUS loans go to lower-income households and 30 % of oldsters are behind or in default on their funds. Somewhat sarcastically, given the backlash in opposition to tightening lending requirements 10 years in the past, monetary assist director Kevin Barnes blames the college’s excessive default charge on the federal authorities for permitting dangerous debtors to take out loans within the first place.

“We don’t issue the credit decisions,” Barnes tells Newsweek. “We’re not responsible for collecting the payments.”

The Role that Schools Play

Colleges do have a hand, although, in steering households to PLUS loans. Parents not often find out about this borrowing choice till a university monetary assist officer tells them, Fossey says. And some faculties actively push mother and father to borrow as an alternative of their kids, in keeping with Mayotte and different specialists, so as to preserve their pupil default charges down.

That’s as a result of a university or college stands to lose important federal funding if 30 % or extra of its pupil debtors are in default for 3 consecutive yr or 40 % or extra default in a single yr. But there is not a comparable rule related to dad or mum loans.

“For the institutions, Parent PLUS loans are like a grant. They get the money regardless of what it does to the family.”

“For the institutions, Parent PLUS loans are like a grant,” stated Rachel Fishman, deputy director for greater training analysis at New America, a Washington, D.C. suppose tank. “They get the money regardless of what it does to the family.”

There’s no manner of realizing what number of establishments put strain on mother and father to borrow. Some faculties, as a matter of coverage, don’t point out PLUS loans until a pupil has exhausted different technique of paying for his or her training and remains to be arising quick. Case in level: At Wayne State University in Detroit, the place simply 7 % of the college’s greater than 1,000 dad or mum debtors defaulted in 2017-19, PLUS loans are thought to be a final resort.

FE_Parent Debt_07
Wayne State University in Detroit, the place dad or mum loans are a final resort.
Raymond Boyd/Getty

“We found that parents don’t always understand the implications of borrowing,” says Catherine Kay, Wayne State’s senior director of economic assist. “If you offer these loans from the front end, people sometimes borrow more than they need to. A parent could potentially borrow every year and the debt really adds up.”

The University of New Orleans leaves all loans out of its preliminary assist gives, however does present them as a ultimate choice, stated Ann Lockridge, the monetary assist director on the public college, the place fewer than 80 mother and father used PLUS loans in 2017-19. The college had a 13 % default charge in these years. By distinction, each Philander Smith and LeMoyne-Owen say they supply Parent PLUS loans as a financing choice from the beginning.

It’s a difficult conundrum for schools and universities, lots of which rely upon sustaining regular enrollment for his or her survival. Smaller personal schools particularly rely upon tuition, so dropping Parent PLUS loans as a financing choice might have dire penalties, they are saying.

Dillard University in New Orleans, the place 15 % of dad or mum debtors default, tried downplaying PLUS loans as an choice a few years in the past by mentioning them solely as a backup plan, solely to lose potential college students who now not noticed Dillard as an reasonably priced choice, says David Page, vp for enrollment administration on the personal, traditionally Black college. Families seemed on the financing choices the college provided upfront, similar to scholarships, grants and conventional pupil loans, and did not see a technique to pay, he says.

“Ultimately it is their choice,” says Page. “I think schools should have the opportunity to create whatever plan they find appropriate for their students.”

FE_Parent Debt_04
Parents usually borrow almost $67,000 to place their baby by way of NYU—one of many highest mortgage burdens within the nation. Here: this yr’s graduation in New York City.
Liao Pan/China News Service/Getty

Default Is Not the Only Danger

Parents, nonetheless, face some distinctive challenges in repaying their loans in comparison with pupil debtors. The most blatant one: They don’t have as a lot time left of their working lives to pack again what they owe and, usually already at or previous their earnings peak, they can not depend on a rising earnings to make compensation simpler sooner or later.

The quantities they owe are normally a lot bigger too, since they will borrow as much as the total price of attendance annually and should take out loans for a number of kids.

If mother and father run into issues making funds, although, they don’t have entry to as a lot assist as their youngsters do. Parents are solely eligible for one of many federal authorities’s 4 income-based compensation plans, which decrease the quantity due every month by stretching funds past the usual 10-year schedule. Parents can change to a plan that limits funds to nor greater than 20 % of discretionary earnings over 25 years, whereas the plans college students generally use restrict fee to 10 % of earnings.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, in a 2017 report, documented the hardships pupil loans typically end in for debtors age 60 and older. It reported that a big portion battle to pay primary residing bills and are extra doubtless than same-aged folks with out pupil loans to skip going to the physician or dentist or shopping for pharmaceuticals as a result of they can not afford it. They’ve additionally saved much less for retirement and a rising portion have had a portion of their Social Security advantages offset due to unpaid pupil loans.

Phi Linh Ellis, a 38-year-old New Orleans pharmacist, is already anticipating the pressure PLUS-loan funds will placed on her household’s funds. She and her husband borrowed $7,500 to assist pay for his or her son’s freshman yr on the University of Holy Cross this previous yr and anticipate to owe not less than $60,000 by the point he graduates. And the couple have two youthful kids in daycare who’re more likely to want their very own tuition help sometime.

“Any time you have a new debt you have to cut back on costs: groceries, eating out, anything that’s not a fixed cost,” says Ellis, who completed repaying her personal pupil loans just some years in the past. “It does stress me out, especially knowing I have other children behind my son.”

Repayment could be much more difficult for retired mother and father. A 2015 GAO report discovered that there have been 870,000 or so pupil mortgage debtors over age 65, of which 210,000 owed Parent PLUS mortgage debt; a whole bunch of 1000’s extra doubtless had personal loans, typically co-signed with their kids. Overall, the CFPB discovered that just about three-quarters of school debtors age 60 and older took out the loans on behalf of their kids and grandchildren.

Even debtors who’re extra ready for the PLUS debt discover themselves greatly surprised by it. Take New York City residents Lee Johnson and his spouse, a retired nurse, who borrowed about $160,000 to ship their son to the University of Florida in 2004 and their daughter to Spelman in 2008. The Johnsons did their homework, by no means missed a fee and have since paid off the loans in full. But they have been nonetheless shocked by the excessive rates of interest—round 7 % on the time—and the way rapidly the debt added up.

“This is a big trap for poor people.”

“I went to school for economics, so I understand the tricks of the trade but the average person knows nothing about this,” says Johnson, 65, a retired truck driver. “This is a big trap for poor people.”

For many mother and father, the struggles they face repaying PLUS loans may be price it if borrowing achieved the specified end result: getting their baby a university diploma. But lots of the faculties with the very best default charges have a commencement charge far decrease than the 63 % nationwide common.

Consider Stevens-Henager College, a Utah-based college owned by the Center for Excellence in Higher Education, which has repeatedly confronted criticism about its high quality from graduates, accreditors and judges. Nearly 40 % of PLUS debtors at Stevens-Henager and its associated Independence University defaulted inside two years. Meanwhile, the eight-year commencement charge is simply 32 %, in keeping with the Department of Education.

The school chain has a division meant to stop defaults, however hasn’t been in a position to get a deal with on PLUS debtors, says Scott Schuler, vp of economic assist for the colleges.

Close behind Stevens-Henager is Centura College, a for-profit college in Virginia the place 38 % of PLUS debtors defaulted inside two years and simply 43 % of scholars graduated in eight years. The school gives “intensive” monetary counseling for its college students, says Joel English, Centura’s govt vp however “for parents, we don’t have such a program.”

Solutions Proposed, None Taken

What’s to be executed? Student mortgage forgiveness was a sizzling matter within the presidential marketing campaign and earlier this yr however not one of the proposals floated explicitly addressed dad or mum debt. Since then, President Biden has stated he’s trying into forgiveness choices, but it surely’s not clear how that will work or whether or not his plan will embody mother and father both. Several specialists instructed Newsweek they are not satisfied Biden will take motion in any respect, regardless of strain inside his personal occasion to take action, noting the president didn’t embody pupil debt forgiveness in his proposed funds or infrastructure laws.

Congress might take the lead in attempting to implement an answer. But whereas legislators have often tried reforms, outcomes are uncommon. “It certainly seems like an area that needs a champion,” says Democratic Representative Eric Swalwell of California, who tells Newsweek he intends this yr to reintroduce a 2019 invoice he proposed to wipe out curiosity on federal pupil loans, together with Parent PLUS debt.

FE_Parent Debt_10
Advocates of mortgage forgiveness make their emotions recognized yet one more time exterior the White House final month.
Paul Morigi/We The 45 Million/Getty

Meanwhile, Representative Bill Foster, a Democrat from Illinois, tells Newsweek he hopes to suggest a invoice this yr that can permit graduates to take over their mother and father’ college loans. But that will not handle what Foster says is the true driver of excessive school debt: state and federal training funds cuts which have pushed faculties to lift tuition repeatedly in recent times. He says, “We seem to have just lost that social compact.”

The Department of Education might reform facets of the Parent PLUS loans with out congressional approval, but it surely’s not clear whether or not it can. The division didn’t reply to repeated interview requests.

Still, just a few comparatively minor adjustments might assist giant numbers of debtors, specialists say. Mayotte, for instance, suggests permitting college students to cosign dad or mum loans, which might allow them to take over some accountability for the debt if the dad or mum runs into monetary hassle. She additionally advocates broadening the income-based compensation choices accessible to folks.

And each Mayotte and Fishman urge the federal authorities to pay extra consideration to a possible borrower’s capacity to repay the mortgage earlier than permitting the dad or mum to signal the contract.

For occasion, Fishman says, the Department of Education might use data gathered within the FAFSA—the federal software for pupil assist—to find out whether or not a household has the monetary means to repay a mortgage earlier than providing one. A easy credit score verify shouldn’t be sufficient, she notes, as a result of it typically results in mother and father with no credit score historical past, and subsequently no blemishes on their document, being eligible for loans they can not afford.

Both Fishman and Baum additionally advocate increasing grant assist to lower-income households to reduce the necessity for loans within the first place. Baum’s analysis exhibits that an additional $6,000 a yr in Pell grants for 4 years, up from the present most of $6,345 now for the lowest-income debtors, would wipe out the necessity for PLUS loans for about three-quarters of oldsters with incomes beneath the poverty stage, together with 85 % of low-income Black PLUS debtors.

Schools additionally must do their half, these specialists say. Tuition and costs have greater than doubled prior to now 30 years at each private and non-private schools and universities, in keeping with the College Board, and the added prices have required households to hunt new methods to pay.

“Borrowing is a symptom of a cost disease. It’s very expensive to go to college. The rest of the aid hasn’t kept pace.”

If faculties scale back the price of training and the federal authorities gives more cash for Pell grants, mother and father will not must borrow as a lot cash, stated Fishman, of New America. “Borrowing is a symptom of a cost disease,” she says. “It’s very expensive to go to college and it’s expensive to cover living expenses. The rest of the aid hasn’t kept pace.”

In the meantime, their experiences with PLUS loans have mother and father like Michele and Paul Billich, small enterprise house owners in South Plainfield, New Jersey, rethinking their choices for paying for faculty. The couple took out two PLUS loans totaling $49,000 for his or her daughter beginning in 2009 because the financial system fell off the desk; they ultimately closed the household construction-equipment firm and, a dozen years after they first borrowed for faculty, they nonetheless owe just a few thousand {dollars}. Says Michele, “We just didn’t think we would be holding onto the debt for this long.”

When it got here time to ship their two youthful kids to school, the household selected to not use PLUS loans, deciding the children ought to have extra of a monetary stake in their very own training.

Phil Bender, nonetheless sitting on $300,000 in pupil loans in Florida, can also be questioning what he might have executed in another way. “Being strapped to this sort of debt into my 80s isn’t something I look forward to,” he says. All three of his daughters are planning to assist pay again the loans, he says, however he is aware of he’ll in all probability find yourself working lengthy into what was presupposed to be his retirement.

While he has regrets, although, Bender is not positive what else he and his spouse might have executed to pay for his or her daughters’ training. “If I had to do it over again, I don’t know if I would have done anything differently or not,” he says. “I had the opportunity to go to college and I wanted my daughters to have the opportunity to go to college. What else can a parent hope for?”

Matt Krupnick is a contract journalist primarily based in Los Angeles. His reporting has appeared in The New York Times, The Guardian, The Washington Post and the Hechinger Report, amongst different publications.

FE_Parent Debt_COVER
Illustration by Alex Fine for Newsweek

Leave a Comment