Do People Who Don’t Have Student Debt Care About Student Loan Forgiveness?

As President-Elect Joe Biden continues to face strain to cancel scholar mortgage debt when he takes workplace in January, folks on Twitter have weighed in on an necessary dialogue: do individuals who haven’t got debt or have paid off their scholar loans care if debt is cancelled for everybody?

Some individuals are fearful about potential backlash ought to Biden cancel faculty debt in his first 100 days. “Those with college debt will be thrilled, of course. But lots and lots of people who didn’t go to college or who worked to pay off their debts? Gonna be bad,” The Week columnist Damon Linker tweeted

I believe Dems are wildly underestimating the depth of anger faculty mortgage cancelation goes to impress. Those with faculty debt might be thrilled, in fact. But heaps and much of people that did not go to varsity or who labored to repay their money owed? Gonna be dangerous.

— Damon Linker (@DamonLinker) November 16, 2020

Others voiced their issues, seemingly about elevated taxes ought to scholar debt be cancelled. Social media editor for conservative information website The Blaze Jessica O’Donnell tweeted that the folks paying could be “the people who already paid for our student loans.” Another mentioned that he wished cash he spent on group faculty refunded.

You’re not “canceling” a debt. You’re transferring it. Someone has to pay.

And it’s going to be the individuals who already paid for our scholar loans as a result of we labored laborious and mentioned “no” to a number of enjoyable issues the oldsters with debt selected to say “yes” to.

— Jessica O’Donnell (@heckyessica) November 17, 2020

All I do know is that if these folks get their scholar loans paid off, I higher get refunded for the $3,899 I spent on group faculty.

— Jesse Kelly (@JesseKellyDC) November 17, 2020

While various folks expressed their worries, others who’ve paid off loans, like How to Be an Antiracist writer Ibram X. Kendi mentioned they supported efforts to cancel debt. Kendi additionally criticized folks for “trying to drive wedges between the American people” with the controversy. Another person weighed in saying that she made sacrifices to repay scholar debt (in addition to different debt she incurred alongside the best way), however argued that she’d be joyful to cancel scholar debt in order that others would not should cope with the identical degree of stress.

As somebody who has paid off my scholar loans, I absolutely assist the Democrats cancelling scholar loans. What makes me indignant is people who find themselves making an attempt to drive wedges between the American folks on a problem that ought to convey us collectively on this second of mass financial struggling.

— Ibram X. Kendi (@DrIbram) November 17, 2020

I’ve paid a number of hundred {dollars} in scholar loans each month since I graduated faculty. I’ve by no means missed a fee. When I used to be first beginning my profession that meant skipping meals and bank card debt. I’d love for no person else to ever should really feel that stress.

— Ari Drennen ❄️ (@AriDrennen) November 17, 2020

i labored a number of jobs by means of faculty & paid off all of my scholar loans myself. i might be THRILLED when people who find themselves nonetheless in scholar mortgage debt get reduction through mortgage cancellation. folks have to cease wanting others to endure simply because they assume they suffered.

— tyler oakley (@tyleroakley) November 16, 2020

Ocasio-Cortez weighed in, criticizing those that are arguing in opposition to cancelling the debt. Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar responded to Linker’s tweet with an identical rebuttal. Senator Bernie Sanders additionally made the argument that public faculty tuition in nations like Germany, France and extra is free, and that the U.S. ought to comply with swimsuit.

“Things were bad for me, so they should stay bad for everyone else” just isn’t a superb argument in opposition to debt cancellation – scholar, medical, or in any other case. #CancelStudentDebt

— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) November 16, 2020

I believe you’re wildly underestimating the anger of hundreds of thousands of individuals whose desires have been held again or delayed due to the burden of scholar mortgage debt.

It’s past time to cancel each penny of scholar debt, and polling exhibits that almost all of voters are on board.

— Ilhan Omar (@IlhanMN) November 16, 2020

Cost of public faculty tuition:

Germany: $0
France: $0
Sweden: $0
Norway: $0
Finland: $0
Brazil: $0
United States: $10,486

In the richest nation on the planet, sure, we should make public faculties and commerce faculties tuition-free and cancel all scholar debt.

— Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders) November 17, 2020

Some folks have used humor to elucidate why folks ought to assist cancelling the debt. One author in contrast it to paying for lifeguards, even when folks know easy methods to swim. Comedian Jaboukie Young-White made a hilarious darkish joke, likening scholar debt to the illness ALS. “[N]ot wanting people to cancel student debt bc you already paid is like Lou Gehrig coming back to a Lou Gehrig’s disease fundraiser like ‘Halt,'” he tweeted.

not wanting folks to cancel scholar debt bc you already paid is like Lou Gehrig coming again to a Lou Gehrig’s illness fundraiser like “Halt.”

— giabuchi lastrassi (@jaboukie) November 16, 2020

The argument in opposition to scholar debt forgiveness is actually:

“Why should my city pay for lifeguards when I know how to swim?”

— michaelharriot (@michaelharriot) November 17, 2020

Sure scholar mortgage forgiveness would free numerous folks from debt peonage however take into consideration how indignant that might make some hypothetical egocentric asshole who positively isn’t me

— Ken Klippenstein (@kenklippenstein) November 16, 2020

Many others used the “Trolley Problem” meme to indicate how problematic it may be to argue in opposition to cancelling scholar debt. In the inversion of the basic ethics query, the trolley has already run over a gaggle of individuals, whereas there is a chance to divert it, earlier than operating over one other group. The bystander on the swap satirically asks, “Would it be fair to the people the trolley has already killed to divert it now?”

Student Debt
Students protest the rising prices of scholar loans for greater schooling on Hollywood Boulevard on September 22, 2012 within the Hollywood part of Los Angeles, California.
David McNew/Getty

Leave a Comment