Could Period-Tracking Apps Be Dangerous in a Post-Roe v. Wade U.S.?

Millions of individuals within the U.S. and the world over depend on period-tracking apps to watch their menstrual cycles, predict fertile home windows and test their signs over time.

And but, a know-how that was basically created to allow ladies to higher know their our bodies could be changed into an instrument to regulate and curb their reproductive rights, abortion-rights activists are warning.

Reproductive Surveillance Concerns

In the follow-up of the leaked draft opinion revealing that the Supreme Court is on the point of probably overturn Roe v. Wade over the summer season, abortion-rights activists are warning individuals in opposition to utilizing period-tracking apps.

These apps know an terrible lot about what is going on on with their customers’ our bodies, together with particulars about their moods, their intercourse lives, their libido, and even the colour and consistency of vaginal discharge.

Roe v Wade Supreme Court
Activists have raised issues over period-tracking apps being probably used as proof of individuals having an abortion. Above, abortion-rights activists exhibit in entrance of the U.S. Supreme Court on May 4, 2022, in Washington, D.C.
Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

But interval apps, not like docs, usually are not sure to affected person privateness guidelines underneath the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), a federal legislation from 1996 which requires delicate sufferers’ info to be saved confidential and never disclosed with out the affected person’s information and consent. The information collected by these period-tracking apps are sometimes bought to third-party firms, like Facebook and Google.

The most well-known and fashionable of those period-tracking apps, Flo, was discovered to have shared the well being information of its customers with advertising and analytics firms between 2016 and 2019, as reported by The New York Times, which mentions a criticism filed by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in January 2021.

After a settlement reached with the FTC, Flo agreed to bear an impartial evaluation of its privateness practices and to ask for customers’ consent earlier than sharing their well being info with third-party firms.

Flo stated that in 2019 it used Facebook Analytics device solely to make sure “the best experience” for customers of the app. According to the corporate, “any use of these tools was for internal development only to improve our functionality and service to our users, not for advertising purposes.”

The firm stated a privateness audit in March 2022 discovered that there have been no gaps in Flo’s privateness practices, and the corporate now says they don’t share their information with third events.

But activists are actually involved about one thing worse than having their private information monetized. They’re warning in opposition to period-tracking apps probably sharing customers’ intimate particulars to trace ladies in search of an abortion.

“If you think that your data showing when you last menstruated isn’t of interest to those who are about to outlaw abortion, whew do I have a wakeup call for YOU,” progressive legal professional and activist Elizabeth C. McLaughlin wrote on Twitter.

How Could These Intimate Data Be Used Against Women Seeking Abortions?

If the Supreme Court was to make its draft opinion remaining and a majority of the judges had been to resolve to overrule Roe v. Wade, abortion would go from being a constitutional proper to being on the mercy of state laws.

It is estimated that 13 states would instantly ban abortions because of the Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade, and extra may be part of them within the following months.

Only 48 hours after the draft doc was leaked by Politico on Monday night time, Louisiana Republican lawmakers accredited a invoice that, if handed by the complete House of Representatives, would classify abortion as a murder.

Such proposed laws offers the complete image of how excessive the stakes are for ladies utilizing period-tracking apps, whose intimate well being information may probably be shared with these eager to prosecute them and put them in jail for all times, and even sentence them to demise.

McLaughlin and others concern that the well being information shared on period-tracking apps might be the targets of subpoenas and courtroom orders to show a being pregnant and criminalize a being pregnant loss—whether or not that’s abortion or a miscarriage.

“Prosecutors have subpoena power, and in the event that you need an abortion or you miscarry or you travel across state lines, you need to think very seriously about what is on your phone,” McLaughlin wrote.

But period-tracking apps usually are not the one motive why individuals in search of abortions needs to be cautious of their telephones: places, Google searches, and chat histories can already be used to find out whether or not somebody is visiting an abortion clinic, or even when they’re contemplating doing so.

There are precedents of individuals—together with personal residents in addition to police—shopping for information to analyze abortions and determine individuals who have visited Planned Parenthood clinics. This week, Vice revealed the results of an investigation that discovered {that a} location information agency was promoting information revealing the place individuals who visited a Planned Parenthood clinic got here from and the place they went afterward to anybody prepared to spend $160.

Whether the secrets and techniques contained in individuals’s telephones might be used in opposition to ladies in search of a prohibited abortion in a post-Roe v. Wade‘s future remains to be unsure—however it stays a grim chance.

Update 05/09/22, 6:05 a.m. ET: This article has been up to date so as to add a remark from Flo.

Leave a Comment